Is Dialectic safe and trustworthy?

tashan scores Dialectic on public evidence — tashan score 24.0/100, it is currently abandoned. Audit scope: OSV advisories, install-time scripts, build provenance and declared permission surface. We do not review source code or execute the capability.

How do I install Dialectic?

Configure it from its source repository — it is a remote / registry server.

Who maintains Dialectic?

2 GitHub contributors, source: urav06/dialectic.

‹ The Index

Dialectic

plugin

Computational argumentation system for structured AI debates using Toulmin framework

Works with: Claude Code (native)
native: this artifact type is that client's own format

Install (Claude Code):

/plugin marketplace add urav06/dialectic
/plugin install dialectic@dialectic-marketplace

solid

“5 worked examples; short of deep on per-tool docs and setup/auth”

This grade is wrong ›

Looking for a replacement? npx tashan-cli doctor is free and tells you everything above about your whole config. tashan Pro names the replacement — which one, and how it measures. $6/mo.

tashan score: 24.0
Instruction depth: 64.0 (solid — documents the job properly, with examples you could follow)
Adoption: 1 repos
Upkeep: 52.0
Freshness: 36.0
Evidence coverage: 84% of the inputs this score can use — the rest are unknown, and the score is discounted for it
Health: abandoned
GitHub stars: 6
Contributors: 2
License: MIT

Security audit

Not scanned yet. We audit npm-published capabilities for known advisories, install-time scripts and permission surface; this one has no npm package we can resolve, or has not reached the queue.

You searched for one. Check the rest of your stack:

npx tashan-cli doctor

Reads the config already on your machine and names what is dead, deprecated or running code at install time. No account, nothing uploaded.

tashan Pro$6/mo

Dialectic scores 24 today. Pro keeps the series, so you can see whether that is a project getting better or one on its way down.

The whole series behind any row, back to the first day we measured it
The replacement, named — not just the news that something died
tashan doctor over your own config, on your own machine

Start a 7-day trial › Everything measured on this page stays free.

Show your score

Measured this well? Put the live badge in your README — it updates as the score does.

[![tashan](https://tashan.sh/badge/plugin-urav06-dialectic-dialectic.svg)](https://tashan.sh/capability/plugin-urav06-dialectic-dialectic.html)

source ↗ · plugin:urav06/dialectic/dialectic

Everything on this page is public evidence and free. What it cannot know is whether you run this — check your whole config, free, in the browser. tashan Pro adds the series behind each row and names a replacement for anything dying.

Already running this? Check your whole config — free, in your browser, nothing installed. Or npx tashan-cli doctor locally, which sends nothing at all.

Measured 2026-09-13 · scorer s5 · how · something wrong here?