Is Roundtable safe and trustworthy?

tashan scores Roundtable on public evidence — tashan score 57.0/100, it is currently active. Audit scope: OSV advisories, install-time scripts, build provenance and declared permission surface. We do not review source code or execute the capability.

How do I install Roundtable?

Configure it from its source repository — it is a remote / registry server.

Who maintains Roundtable?

3 GitHub contributors, source: wan-huiyan/agent-review-panel.

‹ The Index

Roundtable

plugin

Orchestrate a multi-agent adversarial review panel. 4-6 reviewers with distinct personas independently evaluate work, debate findings across 1-3 rounds, then a supreme judge renders the final verdict. Bundles plan-review-integrator for applying findings back into implementation plans. Auto-detected Precise/Exhaustive mode, severity verification, tiered L0/L1/L2 knowledge mining, 10 signal groups with domain checklists. Based on ChatEval, AutoGen, DMAD, CONSENSAGENT, and Trust or Escalate researc

Works with: Claude Code (native)
native: this artifact type is that client's own format

Category: Security — see all ranked ›

Work: Code review · Agent development

Who it is for: Software engineer · AI engineer

Install (Claude Code):

/plugin marketplace add wan-huiyan/agent-review-panel
/plugin install roundtable@agent-review-panel

deep

“states $3-20 per run and that all reviewers share one base model, so it is self-critique”

This grade is wrong ›

tashan score: 57.0
Instruction depth: 88.0 (deep — documents every tool, with worked examples, setup and a stated limitation)
Adoption: 1 repos
Upkeep: 94.0
Freshness: 87.0
Evidence coverage: 84% of the inputs this score can use — the rest are unknown, and the score is discounted for it
Health: active
GitHub stars: 30
Contributors: 3
License: MIT

Security audit

Not scanned yet. We audit npm-published capabilities for known advisories, install-time scripts and permission surface; this one has no npm package we can resolve, or has not reached the queue.

What changed recently

2026-08-05 the tashan score for roundtable rose to 62.0, from 54.0 Upkeep, freshness or adoption moved enough to change how this measures.

You are reading this because you came looking. tashan Pro gives tashan doctor the history behind it, so a run over your own config says which of YOURS moved.

You searched for one. Check the rest of your stack:

npx tashan-cli doctor

Reads the config already on your machine and names what is dead, deprecated or running code at install time. No account, nothing uploaded.

tashan Pro$6/mo

We recorded 1 change to Roundtable in the last 45 days. Pro tells you on the day — for the servers in your own config, not the ones you thought to look up.

The whole series behind any row, back to the first day we measured it
The replacement, named — not just the news that something died
tashan doctor over your own config, on your own machine

Start a 7-day trial › Everything measured on this page stays free.

Show your score

Measured this well? Put the live badge in your README — it updates as the score does.

[![tashan](https://tashan.sh/badge/plugin-wan-huiyan-agent-review-panel-roundtable.svg)](https://tashan.sh/capability/plugin-wan-huiyan-agent-review-panel-roundtable.html)

source ↗ · plugin:wan-huiyan/agent-review-panel/roundtable

Already running this? Check your whole config — free, in your browser, nothing installed. Or npx tashan-cli doctor locally, which sends nothing at all.

Measured 2026-09-13 · scorer s5 · how · something wrong here?