# Critique · benjaroy

> | Give a thorough, honest critique of a complete or near-complete essay, ranked by severity and capped at 600 words. Open with the single most important thing to fix. Close with simulated social media reactions. Use this skill whenever someone has a finished draft and wants a detailed assessment. Trigger when the user mentions critiquing, reviewing, getting feedback on, assessing, or evaluating writing. Also trigger for "how is this?", "what's working and what isn't?", "be honest with me about this," or "give me a thorough read." For quick check-ins or vague requests, use /riff instead.

## Facts
- Page: https://tashan.sh/capability/skill-benjaroy-critique
- tashan id: skill:benjaroy/critique
- Source: https://github.com/benjaroy/riff
- Type: skill
- Category: design
- tashan score: not scored (catalogued only — too little public evidence)
- Adoption: 9.0
- Upkeep: 65.0
- Freshness: 63.0
- Evidence coverage: 84% of the inputs this score can use
- Health: active
- Instruction depth: not yet graded
- License: MIT
- Official: no

## Install

```sh
cp -r critique ~/.claude/skills/
```

## Security audit
Not scanned. We audit npm-published capabilities; this one has no npm package we can resolve, or has not reached the queue. This is not a clean bill of health.

---
Measured 2026-08-14 by tashan (https://tashan.sh) from public evidence. Scorer s5.