Is Guild Codex Review safe and trustworthy?

tashan scores Guild Codex Review on public evidence — it is currently abandoned. Audit scope: OSV advisories, install-time scripts, build provenance and declared permission surface. We do not review source code or execute the capability.

How do I install Guild Codex Review?

Don't. This capability has been discontinued by its author or publisher and is not scored or recommended. If you are already running it, `npx tashan-cli doctor` will flag it and name what to move to.

‹ The Index

Guild Codex Review

skill

DEPRECATED lifecycle entry-point (D-BR-A) — now the internal Codex adapter invoked BY guild:review-broker, never called directly from Guild lifecycle gates. Route --review=cross / review: cross to guild:review-broker. Survives as the Codex-specific adapter: dispatches codex:codex-rescue against an artifact, loops until SATISFIED on its own line (cap=5 rounds, --codex-cap=N), writes trail to .guild/runs/<run-id/codex-review/<gate.md, skips gracefully when codex --version fails. TRIGGER on: \"invoke the Codex adapter\", \"codex adapter for gate\", \"dispatch codex adversarial review\", \"run Codex critique on artifact\", \"one-off Codex gate review\". …

Works with: Claude Code (native) · Cursor, Codex CLI (manual)
native: this artifact type is that client's own format

Discontinued — do not install. The author's own notice: “DEPRECATED lifecycle entry-point (D-BR-A) — now the internal Codex adapter invoked BY `guild:review-broker`, never called directly from Guild lifecycle gates. Route `--review=cross` / `review: cross`” It stays listed so anyone already running it can find this page, and so npx tashan-cli doctor can warn about it. It is not scored and does not appear in any ranking.

Looking for a replacement? npx tashan-cli doctor is free and tells you everything above about your whole config. tashan Pro names the replacement — which one, and how it measures. $6/mo.

Adoption: 1 repos
Health: abandoned

Security audit

Not scanned yet. We audit npm-published capabilities for known advisories, install-time scripts and permission surface; this one has no npm package we can resolve, or has not reached the queue.

Its own instructions

Its SKILL.md shows worked examples, covers setup and states a limitation.

Read from the capability’s own SKILL.md. This is not a grade and does not compare to the instruction-depth verdict on an MCP server — a skill has no tools to document, so that rubric does not apply to it.

You searched for one. Check the rest of your stack:

npx tashan-cli doctor

Reads the config already on your machine and names what is dead, deprecated or running code at install time. No account, nothing uploaded.

tashan Pro$6/mo

Pro adds the history to tashan doctor, so a run over your own config says which of yours gained an advisory, started running an install script, or lost its last maintainer — and what to move to.

Every score since we started measuring, for any capability
The named replacement when something you run is dying — not just that it is
tashan doctor over the config you already have, on your machine

Start a 7-day trial › Everything measured on this page stays free.

source ↗ · skill:lookatitude/guild-codex-review

Everything on this page is public evidence and free. What it cannot know is whether you run this — npx tashan-cli doctor reads your own config and names what is wrong in it, also free. tashan Pro tells you the day any of it changes.

Already running this? npx tashan-cli doctor checks your whole config against the Index — how it works ›

Measured 2026-08-14 · scorer s5 · how · something wrong here?