Question 1

Is Shadcn UI or Semiotic better?

Accepted Answer

Semiotic scores 77.0 and Shadcn UI scores 73.0 on the tashan score, which measures upkeep and freshness gated by real adoption. Neither number is a security audit and neither can be bought. The gap is narrow, so compare the evidence rather than the headline.

Question 2

Are Shadcn UI and Semiotic safe to install?

Accepted Answer

Shadcn UI: no known advisories, no build provenance. Semiotic: no known advisories, no build provenance. Every capability tashan measures is checked against the OSV advisory database at the version you would install today, for install-time scripts and for build provenance. The audit reads public evidence and never executes anything.

Question 3

How were these two compared?

Accepted Answer

Both were measured on the same day by the same scorer, from public signal only — npm download volume and publish cadence, repository activity, maintainer count and registry status. Nobody can pay to change a score, a rank or a listing.

	Shadcn UI	Semiotic	what it means
tashan score	73	77	upkeep + freshness, gated by adoption
Adoption evidence	3k/wk	10k/wk	the raw public signal the score came from
Last release	active	active	npm publish or repo push
Upkeep	82	87	cadence, maintainers, status
Expertise grade	solid	not graded	an LLM read of its own documentation against a fixed rubric
Security audit	no known advisories, no build provenance	no known advisories, no build provenance	a summary — the full audit, free, is on each dossier
Licence	MIT	—
Maintainers	more than one	more than one	bus-factor risk

Shadcn UI vs Semiotic

Install either